Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Is South Carolina better for minorities than North Carolina?

North Carolina, with liberal enclaves like Chapel Hill and a national political profile as a "purple" state, tends to think of itself as a more progressive place than South Carolina.

A new study out today suggests we might want to think again. The report, from consumer finance website Wallet Hub, ranks South Carolina far more favorably in measuring states with the highest and lowest financial gaps by race and ethnicity. Wallet Hub reached that conclusion after studying 21 metrics across all states, including unemployment rates, home ownership rates, household income rates and educational attainment figures.

Source: WalletHub

The result: Florida comes in at No. 1, having the smallest overall income gaps by racial and ethnic groups. South Carolina ties with Indiana for the 27th spot. North Carolina lands at No. 39, just below North Dakota and just above Georgia. Key stats for North Carolina:

  • A 37.41 percent gap in median household income between whites and blacks.
  • A 42 percent gap in home ownership rates between whites and Latinos.
  • A 177 percent gap in poverty rates between whites and Latinos.
  • A 60 percent gap in highest educational attainment between whites and Latinos.
Why such big gaps? Is it institutional racism and the residual legacy of Jim Crow segregation? Are minorities  not trying hard enough to earn their fair share of the American Dream? Or is the answer more complex for either of those questions?

The study doesn't spell out exactly why North Carolina might fare better or worse than other states on specific measures. But Wallet Hub did ask several economists and scholars for their overall take on the persistence of financial inequities in America.  The growth in real estate values and the rise of the tech economy have contributed to the widening of the wealth gap, several said, since minorities still lag in home ownership and higher education.

One of the experts questioned was Omar Ali, a history professor in the African Diaspora Studies program at UNC Greensboro. Interestingly, he singled out the two major political parties, which he said essentially work in tandem to promote the interests of wealthy individuals and companies that finance their political campaigns. He suggests their policies -- even those by a sitting African American president -- tend to boost established powers more so than the interests of the disadvantaged, who tend to be mostly people of color.

"But it's not the wealthy who are to blame," he adds. "They are simply doing what's most rational (I'm not saying ethical); the problem is at the public policy level, where the parties (which are private entities) have substituted themselves as public entities. We need to increase the power of ordinary voters and decrease the power of the parties in the U.S."

What do you think? Are you surprised that South Carolina ranks better on these measures than North Carolina? Does Ali have a point?

--Eric Frazier


Larry said...

Democrats, becoming rich or richer by telling poor folks how they should hate the rich folks for working so hard.


Larry said...

Oh and notice how obama and the democrats, who worry so much about the little guy, are dependent on their political funding from Lawyers and Law Firms.


And we all know how Lawyers are out looking for the little guy.

Unknown said...

Omar Ali's comment "We need to increase the power of ordinary voters and decrease the power of the parties in the U.S." sounds pretty Libertarian to me.

Not going to happen either; what's your Plan B Omar?

essay best said...

It's high time that people start let go of racism. I mean we all got to appreciate minorities if they are doing better. Why just go out lash on them?

Sophie Grace said...

I like your content and really enjoyed reading it and want to thank you for sharing such nice lines with us. webstagram

Micheal george said...

It is a complex and nuanced issue to compare the treatment of minorities in South Carolina and North Carolina. While there may be some differences, both states have a long way to go in terms of achieving true equality and fairness for all. Investing in education and pay essays on this topic can help shed light on the challenges and progress being made in both states.